We have created a list with the best luxury hotels in Montauk, USA. Hope you enjoy it. We think it might be the best of its kind around. Tip: Set your dates to see room prices!
A list by Sara Lind & Adam Larsen. Updated February 2024.
Charming. Highly elegant. Comfortable beds. Located 500 meters from the village of Montauk, this beachfront property features an outdoor oceanside pool with a sun terrace and a private beach area. Free Wi-Fi is offered. Light rooms decorated in soothing colors offer a dining area and a small refrigerator. Marram rooms and studios are air conditioned and have wood furniture. Walk along the beach to nearby Shadmoor State Park or surf at The Terrace. The property is a short walk to the stores, cafés, restaurants and bars. Montauk Lighthouse is 9.1 km away from the motel. Montauk Downs Golf and Recreation is 2.7 km away. we are screen free . Show full description
Based on my research this is one of the most charming, elegant and unique resorts in Montauk! So NICE!
Resort. Located directly on the beach, Gurney’s Montauk offers year-round accommodation in Montauk, 13.4 km from Montauk Point Lighthouse. Free WiFi access is available. Featuring an ocean view, every room offers a flat-screen cable TV. Each room has a private bathroom with a hairdryer and free toiletries. There is a 24-hour front desk at Gurney’s Montauk, which also features a full-service spa with healing treatments and ocean-fed seawater pool, and sauna. There are five dining and drinking venues available. Hither Hills State Park is 3.7 km away from Gurney’s Montauk, while Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course is 6.9 km away.Show full description
A five-star resort with all amenities possible, including the outside fire pit and bar with comfortable lounging. The cafe in the lobby has unforgettable views.
Resort.Superb breakfast. Situated on Star Island in Lake Montauk, this Long Island resort and spa features a private beach, 3 swimming pools, and boat rentals. Rooms include a private wooden balcony. The accommodations at Montauk Yacht Club are nautical-themed with whitewashed walls and nautical artwork. They are equipped with a flat-screen TV, free WiFi, and iPod docking station. A coffee maker and refrigerator are also provided. This resort offers 3 on-site dining options, including Showfish, The Pool Club and Il Forno. Spa services are offered at this Montauk resort. Volleyball courts, lighted tennis courts, and horseshoe pits are located on the property. Concierge services are available. Rita’s Horse Stables and the Montauk Downs Golf Course are 5 minutes from Montauk Yacht Club. The Montauk Point Lighthouse and Museum is 10 minutes from the resort.Show full description
Delightful property. Historic property. Superb interior design. Offering on-site spa services, Montauk Manor is located in Montauk, New York. The property features an outdoor swimming pool. Free Wi-Fi access is available. Air conditioning, cable TV and a seating area are included in each uniquely decorated room. There is also a full kitchen with a dishwasher and microwave. Private bathrooms are equipped with free toiletries. Guests at Montauk Manor can enjoy the spa and wellness centre and multiple tennis courts. Meeting facilities and luggage storage are also available. An array of activities can be enjoyed on site or in the surroundings, including horse riding and fishing. A complimentary electric car charge is available to guests. Kirk Park Beach is 2.9 km away from the hotel and Montauk Museum is 10.1 km away.Show full description
A beautiful Tudor-style mansion located on a hill just a few steps away from the Main Street of Montauk. The outdoor patio is gorgeous and well kept.
Charming. Trendy. Great value. Popular among women. Located just off Route 27, The Montauk Beach House boasts an outdoor swimming pool, gift shop, café and snack bar. Free Wi-Fi access is available. A flat-screen cable TV is included in each air conditioned guest room. The private bathrooms are equipped with free toiletries. Select rooms have a pool view. Guests can relax poolside or enjoy cocktails in the lounge. There is a DJ on-site every weekend. Clothing, beauty products and more are available in the gift shop. The Beach House in Montauk has a 24-hour front desk. A selection of small plates and sandwiches are available at the café and outdoor grill. Additional dining options including South Edison are located within walking distance. Camp Hero State Park is 7 km away and Hither Hills State Park is 9.3 km away.Show full description
This lovely hotel has a picturesque location close to the beach. The rooms are furnished with Restoration Hardware products.
Lovely property. Cosy rooms. Great location. Located in Montauk, within 1.2 km of Gin Beach and 3.2 km of Fort Pond Bay Park, The Montauk Soundview provides accommodation with an outdoor swimming pool and free WiFi as well as free private parking for guests who drive. This 5-star hotel offers a private beach area and a concierge service. Certain units at the property include a terrace with a sea view. Some rooms will provide you with a kitchen with a fridge, a microwave and a stovetop. Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course is 3.5 km from the hotel, while Montauk Downs State Park is 3.5 km away. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 111 km from The Montauk Soundview.Show full description
Resort.Popular among couples. This Montauk beachfront property is 10 minutes’ drive to the Montauk Point Lighthouse and is less than 1 mile from Montauk town centre. Hero Beach Club offers free WiFi throughout the property. There is an outdoor swimming pool and daily cleaning service for the rooms. In-room massage services can be arranged by the front desk. Each room has cable TV and a private entrance. Some of the rooms have a balcony or deck that offers a view of the ocean. Hero Beach Club is located 3 miles from Ditch Plains Surfing Beach. Fort Pond is less than 1 mile from the property and offers fishing. Fishing is also available at the Fort Pond Harbour which is only 5 minutes’ drive away.Show full description
A lovely hotel with a picnic area and heated pool on a fantastic property with a fire pit. Such an excellent choice for a family stay!
Hip. Romantic. Great breakfast. Popular among women. Situated in Montauk, within 9.5 km of Gin Beach and 5.5 km of Theodore Roosevelt County Park, Haven Montauk provides accommodation with free bikes and a garden, and free WiFi. The bay is a 4-minutes' walk across the street from the property. All guest rooms in the hotel are fitted with a TV and a wardrobe. All rooms have a private bathroom, while some rooms include a kitchenette. Some rooms have a view of the ocean and some rooms have a view of Lake Montauk and the sunset. Haven Montauk offers a seasonal outdoor pool, a fire pit and a barbecue area. 3.4 km from Montauk Downs State Park, the property is also 8.8 km away from Montauk Point State Park. Montauk Racquet Club is 3.7 km away and Navy Park Road is 5 km from the hotel. Montauk train station is 3.2 km away and Block Island Ferry is 300 metres away.Show full description
We do our best to keep this list very up to date. It was last edited in February 2024. If you know of a luxury hotel that should be on the list, let us know. Click here to contact us. Thanks!
Check out these other cool hotel lists for Montauk: